Basket 0

Home › Guides › RDIMM, LRDIMM and UDIMM explained

Server memory explained: RDIMM vs LRDIMM vs UDIMM, ECC and ranks

Desktop and laptop memory comes in one electrical flavour. Server memory comes in three, and choosing the wrong one is the most common reason a server refuses to post after an upgrade. This is what the letters mean, which machines take which, and the mixing rules that catch people out.

Unbuffered, registered, load-reduced

Every module presents its memory chips to the processor’s memory controller. The difference between the three kinds is how much help it gets doing so.

The board decides. A registered module will not post in an unbuffered board and vice versa, without exception. Look for the word in the manual, on the memory QVL, or on the label of what is fitted now (how to read it).

Which do I have?

PlatformTakes
Ordinary desktop, any generationUDIMM, non-ECC
Xeon E3 v3–v6, Xeon E-2xxx, Ryzen Pro, Core with ECC boardECC UDIMM
Xeon E5 v3/v4 (Haswell/Broadwell-EP), DDR4RDIMM or LRDIMM
Xeon Scalable 1st–3rd gen (Skylake to Ice Lake)RDIMM or LRDIMM
Xeon W-2xxx / W-3xxx, Threadripper ProRDIMM (LRDIMM on most)
EPYC 7001/7002/7003RDIMM or LRDIMM
Xeon Scalable 4th gen onwards, EPYC 9004 onwardsDDR5 RDIMM

In vendor terms: Dell PowerEdge R630/R730 and later, HPE ProLiant Gen9 and later, Lenovo ThinkSystem and System x M5 onwards, and Supermicro X10/X11 boards are all DDR4 RDIMM (and LRDIMM) machines. Gen10 Plus, R650/R750 and X12 are also DDR4; the following generation moved to DDR5.

What 2Rx4 means, and why servers care

The rank is the number of independent 64-bit (72 with ECC) groups of chips on the module; the x4 or x8 is the width of each chip. A 16GB 2Rx4 RDIMM and a 16GB 2Rx8 RDIMM hold the same data and both work in nearly any DDR4 server, but they are not identical: x4 modules use more, narrower chips and support the stronger memory-error features (Intel calls it SDDC and ADDDC) on Xeon Scalable and E5. If the server documentation lists a rank for the memory feature you want, match it. Otherwise, either is fine, and mixing them across different channels is normal.

4Rx4 and 4DRx4 are quad-rank and appear on 32GB and 64GB LRDIMMs and on older 32GB RDIMMs. Quad-rank RDIMMs limit how many modules a channel can hold; LRDIMMs exist largely to avoid that.

Mixing rules

Speed and the number of modules

A server rates its memory speed at one module per channel. Fill the second slot in a channel and many platforms drop a step: 2933 to 2666, or 2666 to 2400, particularly with dual-rank modules. This is normal and documented, and it is one reason to prefer fewer, larger modules once every channel already has one.

OEM part numbers

Dell, HPE, Lenovo and Cisco sell standard Samsung, SK hynix and Micron modules under their own part numbers (Dell SNP…, HPE 8xxxxx-B21, Lenovo 4X77A… or 01AG…, Cisco UCS-M…). The module underneath is the same part, and a server will run any module of the right type; the OEM number matters only where a support contract insists on it. Where a module we sell carries an OEM label, the listing quotes that number too.

Why used server memory is a sensible buy

Memory has no wear mechanism. Modules pulled from a decommissioned server were, by definition, running in a working machine the day it was switched off, and a module that passes a full test has no particular reason to fail later. The saving against a new module of the same part number is typically well over half, and on LRDIMMs and 32GB-plus capacities it is larger still. Everything here is tested at rated speed in a server before it is listed and again before it is packed.

Something here not match what you are seeing? Tell us — we would rather correct a guide than process a return.